|
SwiftVets.com Service to Country
|
View previous topic :: View next topic |
Author |
Message |
mikest PO2
Joined: 11 May 2004 Posts: 377
|
Posted: Wed May 12, 2004 4:44 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Quote: | First of all working with Sadr would not be good. He is not respected by most of his country men who view him as a radical and very unstable. He is in the middle of a desperate power grab. Working with him would be a big mistake. Secondly, the problem areas are the poorest ones. Again poverty leads to many of the problems. A way to combat that would be to use less foreign contractors and more Iraqi contractors.
|
Sadr was less influential than Sistani but his influence was still large. I am not saying he should have been given a position of major influence, but consultations with him as we did with Sistani, would have been benaficial in placating him. Working with him now would not only be a mistake but is no longer possible.
Your second point is dead on. And that goes to the fact that there were more political people put into the CPA than people who understood what needed to be done. Add Chalabi to the mix and we have a recipe for disaster. |
|
Back to top |
|
|
Greenhat LCDR
Joined: 09 May 2004 Posts: 405
|
Posted: Wed May 12, 2004 5:29 pm Post subject: |
|
|
mikest wrote: | Hatred of America is at an all time high in the ME. |
And you have arrived at this conclusion how?
Quote: | We left Afghanistan unfinished so we could move onto Iraq. |
I'll tell my friends who are fighting in Afghanistan that we left. _________________ De Oppresso Liber |
|
Back to top |
|
|
mikest PO2
Joined: 11 May 2004 Posts: 377
|
Posted: Wed May 12, 2004 6:10 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Quote: | mikest wrote:
Hatred of America is at an all time high in the ME.
And you have arrived at this conclusion how?
Quote:
We left Afghanistan unfinished so we could move onto Iraq.
I'll tell my friends who are fighting in Afghanistan that we left.
_________________
|
Maybe you've missed the reactions or the comments from leaders such as the King of Jordan, probably our best ally in the ME next to Israel.
As far as Afghanistan, I guess I need to be more literal. We took a major portion of fighters and equipment and money and intel from Afg and put them in Iraq. Instead of persuing Al Queda to their bitter end, we have allowed them to regroup in other nations and continue their mission Imagine the example we could have set if we had left a large force there and made a major effort at reconstruction. If we used even 1/3 of the nearly $2b used for Iraq in Afg, we would have had a giant billboard indicating our best intensions for the region. Instead we have Karzai coming here to beg for more money. |
|
Back to top |
|
|
Greenhat LCDR
Joined: 09 May 2004 Posts: 405
|
Posted: Wed May 12, 2004 6:23 pm Post subject: |
|
|
mikest wrote: | Quote: | mikest wrote:
Hatred of America is at an all time high in the ME.
And you have arrived at this conclusion how?
Quote:
We left Afghanistan unfinished so we could move onto Iraq.
I'll tell my friends who are fighting in Afghanistan that we left.
_________________
|
Maybe you've missed the reactions or the comments from leaders such as the King of Jordan, probably our best ally in the ME next to Israel.
As far as Afghanistan, I guess I need to be more literal. We took a major portion of fighters and equipment and money and intel from Afg and put them in Iraq. Instead of persuing Al Queda to their bitter end, we have allowed them to regroup in other nations and continue their mission Imagine the example we could have set if we had left a large force there and made a major effort at reconstruction. If we used even 1/3 of the nearly $2b used for Iraq in Afg, we would have had a giant billboard indicating our best intensions for the region. Instead we have Karzai coming here to beg for more money. |
Maybe you've missed it, but the King of Jordan was attacked by those terrorists. Maybe you hadn't noticed?
Maybe you think it takes a lot of troops to pursue a few remnants down. I don't think so. But then again, I remember that the entire US contribution of ground troops to overthrowing the Taliban was 24 men, 2 Operational Detachments. _________________ De Oppresso Liber |
|
Back to top |
|
|
mikest PO2
Joined: 11 May 2004 Posts: 377
|
Posted: Wed May 12, 2004 6:30 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I really need to get to work, but there was something I want to say first.
The discussion I have been having with some of you has been truly enjoyable. I disagree with most of you but we have been able to do so with respect and logic/facts. It is one of my favorite things to do.
A quick story.
Last year during the runnup to the war, I met 5 or 6 ex Navy Seals at a dinner party. We got into a very intense and sometimes heated discussion about the war and the administration. Here I was, outmanned by 5 or 6/1 and we just went at it for hours.
At one point the question that always comes up did. Someone asked me if I loved or hated my country. My answer was that there is no way not to love a country where you can criticize the chosen admin of a bunch of guys that can kill you without much effort and not be worried that they will. That to me is one of the things that makes this country the best. Regardless of our disagreements, I think we can all agree on that. |
|
Back to top |
|
|
mikest PO2
Joined: 11 May 2004 Posts: 377
|
Posted: Wed May 12, 2004 6:47 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Quote: | Maybe you've missed it, but the King of Jordan was attacked by those terrorists. Maybe you hadn't noticed?
Maybe you think it takes a lot of troops to pursue a few remnants down. I don't think so. But then again, I remember that the entire US contribution of ground troops to overthrowing the Taliban was 24 men, 2 Operational Detachments.
|
I deserve the sarcasm since I used it on you first. For that I am sorry.
The larger point though is that the King was attacked in part because he backs us. We contiue to give reasons for more moderates not to be able to come to our defence.
As far as AFG goes, our soldiers are unmatched. I'll take 10 of you guys over 100 of theirs in a heartbeat. But it isn't the initial battles that matter the most in cases like this. It is what we do after that indicates what people will think of us, either by omission or comission. And we have done so by omission, not our guys that are there now, but our administration has done it by putting it behind the back burner.
The Afghanistan war was in my opinion the right thing to do. We had an identifiable enemy in Al queda, we had a regime that would make Lou Phelps proud and we had a populace was ready for someone to come in and get them out of their horrible nightmare. Our guys did an amazing job and I am extremely proud of them for that. I just think the admin made a big mistake by taking our eye off the ball and took our best PR chance away in the ME. |
|
Back to top |
|
|
sparky Former Member
Joined: 06 May 2004 Posts: 546
|
Posted: Wed May 12, 2004 6:49 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Quote: | "I'll tell my friends who are fighting in Afghanistan that we left " |
Considering how things are falling apart in Afghanistan, they'd probably agree (unless they consider it their patriotic duty to be cheer leaders).
USA Today Poll: 57% of Iraqis say 'US Out Now'
From March 22 to April 2, 60 trained Iraqi pollsters interviewed 3,444 randomly selected Iraqis for USA Today. This is one of the first polls in Iraq that seems to me well weighted statistically, though to be sure we'd have to know more than USA Today told us.
The numbers are negative for the US, and are much more negative than previous such polls. Moreover, the polling ended by April 2, just before the Shiite uprising and the worst of the Fallujah fighting, as well as the prison photo debacle, so that it is highly likely that the present attitudes of the Iraqi public toward the US are much more negative.
Over half say there are circumstances under which it is all right to attack US troops!
Regarding George Bush, 55% of Iraqis have an unfavorable view of him, and if we exclude the 4 million Kurds and just look at the Arabs, his unfavorable rating is above 60% for both Sunnis and Shiites.
http://www.usatoday.com/news/world/iraq/2004-04-28-poll-cover_x.htm
(with help from Professor Juan Cole)
A CBS Poll of Iraqis looks dismal:
Similarly, 72 percent of Sunni Arabs oppose the presence of coalition forces in Iraq today, compared to 54 percent of Shiite Arabs (and just 12 percent of Kurds). And most threateningly, 36 percent of Sunni Arabs say attacks against coalition forces are "acceptable" — triple the level among Shiite Arabs. Also, 29 percent of Sunni Arabs say coalition forces should leave now, compared with 12 percent of Shiite Arabs.
http://abcnews.go.com/sections/world/WorldNewsTonight/iraq_poll_040317.html
Things aren't much better in Europe, according to a BBC poll:
Poll suggests world hostile to US
People around the world take a dim view of the US, poll suggests
Nearly two-thirds of respondents to an international poll for the BBC say they have an unfavourable opinion of George W Bush.
The survey of 11 countries - for the television programme What The World Thinks of America, to be aired this week in the UK - revealed that 57% of the sample had a very unfavourable, or fairly unfavourable attitude towards the American President.
The figure rose to 60% when discounting the views of the American respondents.
The survey - conducted for the BBC by ICM and other international pollsters - gauged opinion towards US military, economic, cultural and political influence.
Asked who is the more dangerous to world peace and stability, the United States was rated higher than al-Qaeda
(granted, this poll is about a year old, but things have gotten worse in Iraq from a PR perspective.)
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/2994924.stm |
|
Back to top |
|
|
Greenhat LCDR
Joined: 09 May 2004 Posts: 405
|
Posted: Wed May 12, 2004 7:03 pm Post subject: |
|
|
mikest wrote: |
The larger point though is that the King was attacked in part because he backs us. |
Must be why the Palestinians attacked his father 30 years ago.
The King was attacked because he has close ties to the tribes, and doesn't support the Palestinian terrorists. It isn't the first time, and won't be the last. As the recent beheading illustrates, the terrorists don't actually think out their actions and do what is best for themselves, or what maintains focus on one enemy. One of the problems of a cell structure with the communications interdicted. _________________ De Oppresso Liber |
|
Back to top |
|
|
Wondering Seaman Recruit
Joined: 07 May 2004 Posts: 19
|
Posted: Wed May 12, 2004 9:04 pm Post subject: |
|
|
mikest wrote: |
Your second point is dead on. And that goes to the fact that there were more political people put into the CPA than people who understood what needed to be done. Add Chalabi to the mix and we have a recipe for disaster. | I have never liked Chalabi either. |
|
Back to top |
|
|
Wondering Seaman Recruit
Joined: 07 May 2004 Posts: 19
|
Posted: Wed May 12, 2004 9:21 pm Post subject: |
|
|
mikest wrote: |
As far as Afghanistan, I guess I need to be more literal. We took a major portion of fighters and equipment and money and intel from Afg and put them in Iraq. Instead of persuing Al Queda to their bitter end, we have allowed them to regroup in other nations and continue their mission Imagine the example we could have set if we had left a large force there and made a major effort at reconstruction. If we used even 1/3 of the nearly $2b used for Iraq in Afg, we would have had a giant billboard indicating our best intensions for the region. Instead we have Karzai coming here to beg for more money. |
We rooted most of the terrorists and Taliban out of Afghanistan. As targets dried up and those enemy forces slipped into neighboring countries it was time to open a new theater of operation. We couldn't sit around and wait for targets to come back into Afghanistan. You stated yourself that they are regrouping in other nations. Nations that we can not enter at this time. Iraq was one we could enter. So we did. Karzai will always ask for money no matter how much you give him. That is what politicians do. |
|
Back to top |
|
|
jes Seaman Recruit
Joined: 14 May 2004 Posts: 1 Location: Texas
|
Posted: Fri May 14, 2004 2:07 am Post subject: |
|
|
Hello, I would like to introduce myself I am Jes, and though I have never been apart of any of the armed forces, I respect and appreciate your service to our country. I could not help but add a few comments to some of the subject matter. This is a blog from Iraq, who actually lives in Iraq. I thought it would do you guys some good, to know that the military is making a difference over there and it isnt all bad....So here it is...
Old soldier in a new army.
A relative of mine was forced as the millions of Iraqis to serve in Saddam’s army. He was poor and peaceful and couldn’t stand the humiliation and the torture that service meant. He lived in Baghdad and served in Basrah. He was paid about 10 thousand Iraqi Dinars a month, which equaled about 5 US $ at that time, while the ride from his place to his unit cost about 2 or 3 thousand Dinars. Above all he had to bribe the sergeants and the officers only to avoid the hell they could make his life there, as they could’ve made it a lot worse. Others more fortunate paid money to the officer in charge to stay at home and the officer would arrange it to look like they are serving. This may amount to 250-300 thousand Iraqi Dinars a month, and it was a very common practice at that time. And as tens of thousands of Iraqis, he decided to run away. He remained a fugitive for years, hiding from the eyes of the military police. He couldn’t see his family more than 2 or 3 times in the year. We helped him find a job and a place to hide where they couldn’t find him.
Few days ago I was visiting his family to pay our respect in the 1st annual anniversary of his father’s death.
When I saw my relative, and despite the nature of the occasion, I felt happy. Here’s a free man. I smiled as I said, “you must be very happy to be free again, and not fear the MP”. He said, "you can’t imagine! It’s like being born again. I’ve never felt so free before”. “But what are you doing for a living now? I hope you’ve found a job”. I asked. He smiled as he said, "I volunteered in the new army". “Really! I thought you’d never wear a uniform after that terrible experience” he replied "Oh no, this is entirely different". I said, “ I'm sure it is, but who convinced you to do so!? And when did that happen?” "A friend of mine who volunteered before I did told me some nice stuff that encouraged me to do the same, so I volunteered about a couple of months ago". He replied. “So tell me about it, are you happy with this job?” I asked. "You can’t imagine! It’s nothing that we’ve learned or knew about the military life". He answered. “I expected it to be so, but can you tell me about it” I asked and I didn’t have to ask anymore, as my relative started talking excitedly without a stop. He said:
The most important thing is that this army has no retards or illiterate in it like the old one. Now education is an essential requirement when applying to serve in the new army and anyone who hasn’t finished high school at least has no place there. In fact most of the volunteers are college and technical institutes graduates.
Everything is new, no more worn out dirty uniforms that only God knows how many people used before you, and they never minded about the size. This time they took our sizes and handed each one of us a new elegant uniform that’s worthy of an officer! It was a common scene, you know, that soldiers wander near their halls in their underwear after training hours. Some of them did that because they didn’t have much to wear when they wash their uniforms, but the majority did it out of custom. Now this is unacceptable, and everyone received a nice comfortable suit to wear after the training hours.
One of the officers said to us “you know what? One of the reasons you lose your wars is the boots you were wearing” He then handed each one of us a pair of those brand new boots that we could only dream of buying them in the old times, and said “Put these on and you’ll feel like you can fly” and it did feel almost like that!
I knew exactly what my relative meant, as I had to wear those boots at Sadam’s times when they forced us to do a month of military training during our summer vacation in college, and they warned us that anyone who refused to do so would be expelled from his college. Wearing those inflexible rigid boots in that heat was more like a torture. They were my worst memory of that camp and caused me multiple painful sores that needed weeks to heal.
My relative’s face was glowing as he continued, "you can’t imagine how much valued we are and how much our religion and traditions are respected. When we pass by a mosque, the officer in charge shouts “no talk” until we pass the mosque by a considerable distance, and when one of the officers enters our hall, if he sees that one of us is praying he remains silent and order us to keep quite until our comrade finishes his prayer.
For the first time in my life, I feel I’m somebody. I’m not a trash as Saddam and his gang tried to make me believe” as he finished his last words his voice went faint as if he was chocking. I felt his pain and tried to change the course of our talk, “how much do you get paid” I asked, “Oh, pretty much, more than enough, thank God” “and what about your meals” I added and he said with a smile, “Oh you won’t believe it. Everything that we couldn’t get in our own homes before and that we only saw when the officers in the old army made a feast to honor a guest! I mean we have everything; meat is essential in every meal, vegetables, fruits apples and bananas. It’s still unbelievable to many of us!” he went on,
“One of the most important things that the Americans concentrate on in our training is physical fitness. A month ago I could hardly jog for one kilometer before falling to the ground exhausted and out of breath, and now I can run 4-5 kilometers without being exhausted.”
A frown crossed his face as he said “ I remember when they used to train us at the most hot hours of the day for hours without allowing us to rest for a while under a shade or drink any water, and when we get almost killed by thirst, we would be forced to drink from the dirty contaminated ditch water. Now we don’t even drink tap water! Each one of us gets more than enough an amount of that healthy bottled water everyday”
To some people this may mean little if anything, but my relative looked at it as something huge, and indeed, before the war, drinking bottled water was really a luxury that a very small percentage of Iraqis could afford. In my house we used to boil the tap water and cool it before drinking it, because we knew it was not safe and we couldn’t afford buying bottled water everyday.
“I feel I’m somebody now. I’m respected and get all what most people get. Do you believe that they threw one of the Iraqi officers out of the army because he used us to do him personal services, like carrying his bags, and when we complained about his behavior, they told him “ Do you see any of us, American officers use our soldiers? You can go home. You still have the mentality of the old regime and you can’t fit in this new army!” imagine that! They listen to our complains, we the soldiers, and bring us justice even if it involved the higher ranked officers. This had never happened in the old army.”
“But what about the dangers you are going to face when you graduate? You’ll face it everyday, and you’ll probably have to fight Iraqis. Have you thought about that? And how do you feel about it!?” I felt some regret as I asked this question, but it was too important to ignore. My relative said, “Of course I thought about it!” He sighed as he continued, “Dangers were there since I was born; wars, MP chasing me for years, chaos…etc. These will not stop me from going on with my life, and I have a feeling that those thugs are the same people who oppressed me along with all the poor Iraqi soldiers. No, I’m not afraid of them and I’ll do my job. At least this time I know I’m doing the right thing and that my services will be appreciated” I looked at him admiringly as I said, “They are appreciated already! Congratulations, brother, for the new job and for being the free and new man you are”
When I left, I felt real hope in the new Iraqi army. Despite its terrible performance till now, one cannot be pessimistic after hearing the way this army is being formed and the way the soldiers look at it. I’m sure it’ll take time, but I’m also sure that we’ll definitely have an exceptionally efficient, small army with great morals and respect for the law and the institution they represent. An army that can preserve peace and order, and protect the constitution once the Iraqi people agree on one.
-By Mohammed.
Well I hope you liked it....And by the way Al-Sadr is going to be history soon. Most of the Clerics in the south signed some paper giving the US the go ahead to get him....with their blessing... If you would like me to post another blogs information let me know... I dont want to take up to room on this site.....God Bless America and the men and women that protect it!!!! |
|
Back to top |
|
|
academicanarchist Ensign
Joined: 14 May 2004 Posts: 66 Location: Spring, Texas
|
Posted: Fri May 14, 2004 2:12 am Post subject: Iraq |
|
|
Correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't the British try to subdue Iraq after WW l, and found they couldn't do it? McNamara also made the same argument to Johnson about needing more troops. |
|
Back to top |
|
|
Theresa Alwood Rear Admiral
Joined: 05 Jun 2004 Posts: 631 Location: Florida
|
Posted: Sat Jun 12, 2004 6:35 am Post subject: |
|
|
War Dog,
Thank you for protecting our country when you were in Vietnam. I was young when you returned and do not really remember much about it. I was too young to understand. I do now. I respect all veterans and one day would like to shake your hand and say you did a job well done. You did the best you could with what happened in those times. I am proud of all of our vets. Each vet has something unique about them...their love for their country. Doesn't matter which war or peace time you were involved in....a vet is a vet and they should all be put treated with respect as long as they served with dignity. Which you did. |
|
Back to top |
|
|
Marine4life Senior Chief Petty Officer
Joined: 14 May 2004 Posts: 591 Location: California
|
Posted: Sun Jun 13, 2004 11:56 am Post subject: |
|
|
Guy's come on, this is coming from a guy that has not served and has absolutly no knowlege of the military or war. He wouldn't know a good war plan if it hit him in the face. Don't waste your breath, he is here to bash Bush period. They can't let anyone know how effective Bush is, or that the so called allies never have given a rats a** about us unless it would get them money from us. The UN, yea right that's the answer, 90% have voted against us from it's inception everytime then ask us for money. Let me quote the President " I will never ask anyone for permission to defend this great Nation". The giant has awakened, we are doing exactly what we need to do, as we need to do it. So lead, follow or get the hell out of the way!!!! If you don't have a clue, shut up and let the ones who do handle it, your dribble and unknowledgable crap put's my son's life in danger everytime you flap. _________________ Helicopter Marine Attack Squadron 169 which is now HMLA-169. They added Huey's to compliment the Cobra effectiveness. When I served we just had Snakes. |
|
Back to top |
|
|
nakona Lieutenant
Joined: 04 Jun 2004 Posts: 242
|
Posted: Sun Jun 13, 2004 2:48 pm Post subject: |
|
|
jes -
Thank you very much for your post.
Reading it made me very happy and brought tears of joy to my eyes because I know that my brothers and sisters died for a good cause.
Welcome to the Free World.
eric _________________ 13F20P |
|
Back to top |
|
|
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group
|